TY - JOUR
T1 - Resilience and responsibility: Governing uncertainty in a complex world
AU - Welsh, Marc
N1 - Welsh, M. (2014). Resilience and responsibility: Governing uncertainty in a complex world. Geographical Journal, 180 (1), 15-26
Selected by the RGS-IBG as one of twelve papers from Area, The Geographical Journal and Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, for inclusion in the May 2013 Virtual Issue on the theme of the annual conference, titled "New geographical frontiers". These virtual issues collect exemplar papers together with "particular reference to public debates, policy-orientated agendas and notions of ‘relevance’"
PY - 2014/3
Y1 - 2014/3
N2 - ‘Resilience’ has risen to prominence across a range of academic disciplines and political discourses. Situating resilience theories in historical context the paper argues that the resilience discourse of complex adaptive systems, for all its utility as a means for conceptualising and managing change, is allied with contemporary governmental discourses that responsibilise risk away from the state and on to individuals and institutions. Further, in arguing that resilience theories originate in two distinct epistemological communities (natural and social science) in its mobilisation as a ‘boundary object’ resilience naturalises an ontology of ‘the system’. Resilience approaches increasingly structure, not only academic, but also government policy discourses, with each influencing the development of the other. It is argued that by mobilising ‘the system’ as the metaconcept for capturing socio-natural and socio-economic relations resilience theories naturalise and reify two abstractions: firstly, the system itself – enrolling citizens into practices that give it meaning and presence; secondly, the naturalisation of shocks to the system, locating them in a post-political space where the only certainty is uncertainty. With reference to an emerging governmentality through resilience, this paper argues for a critical interrogation of plural resilience theories and wonders at their emancipatory possibilities.
AB - ‘Resilience’ has risen to prominence across a range of academic disciplines and political discourses. Situating resilience theories in historical context the paper argues that the resilience discourse of complex adaptive systems, for all its utility as a means for conceptualising and managing change, is allied with contemporary governmental discourses that responsibilise risk away from the state and on to individuals and institutions. Further, in arguing that resilience theories originate in two distinct epistemological communities (natural and social science) in its mobilisation as a ‘boundary object’ resilience naturalises an ontology of ‘the system’. Resilience approaches increasingly structure, not only academic, but also government policy discourses, with each influencing the development of the other. It is argued that by mobilising ‘the system’ as the metaconcept for capturing socio-natural and socio-economic relations resilience theories naturalise and reify two abstractions: firstly, the system itself – enrolling citizens into practices that give it meaning and presence; secondly, the naturalisation of shocks to the system, locating them in a post-political space where the only certainty is uncertainty. With reference to an emerging governmentality through resilience, this paper argues for a critical interrogation of plural resilience theories and wonders at their emancipatory possibilities.
KW - Complex systems
KW - Governance
KW - Governmentality
KW - Resilience
KW - Responsibility
KW - Risk
UR - https://www.scopus.com/pages/publications/84892973218
U2 - 10.1111/geoj.12012
DO - 10.1111/geoj.12012
M3 - Article
SN - 0016-7398
VL - 180
SP - 15
EP - 26
JO - Geographical Journal
JF - Geographical Journal
IS - 1
ER -