TY - JOUR
T1 - Testing the accuracy of feldspar single grains to date late Holocene cyclone and tsunami deposits
AU - Brill, Dominik
AU - Raimann, Tony
AU - Wallinga, Jacob W.
AU - May, Simon Matthias
AU - Engel, Max
AU - Riedesel, Svenja
AU - Brückner, Helmut
N1 - Funding Information:
Financial support was kindly provided by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft for sample collection in Australia ( MA 5768/1-1 ) and Thailand ( BR 877/27-1 ; BR 877/27-2 ), by the Faculty of Mathematics and Natural Sciences, University of Cologne (UoC), and a UoC postdoctoral grant ( ZUK 81/1 ) for fieldwork in the Philippines, and by the Belgian Science Policy Office ( BELSPO BRAIN-be BR121/A2 ) as part of the QuakeRecNankai project for sampling in Japan. SR acknowledges financial support by an AberDoc PhD scholarship. The research around Exmouth was kindly permitted and supported by Ann Preest, the local elders and aboriginal communities of Exmouth, and the Department of Environment and Conservation (Perth/Exmouth), as well as the owner and managers of Exmouth Gulf station. Hollie Wynne (Aberystwyth University, UK) is thanked for performing beta counting analysis for selected feldspar extracts from Japan, the Philippines and Australia.
Publisher Copyright:
© 2018 Elsevier B.V.
PY - 2018/10/1
Y1 - 2018/10/1
N2 - Quartz is the preferred dosimeter for luminescence dating of Holocene sediments as optically stimulated luminescence (OSL) signals reset rapidly upon light exposure, and are stable over time. However, feldspar is required where quartz luminescence properties are inappropriate for dating, as is often the case in geologically young mountain ranges and areas with young volcanism. Here we aim to evaluate the potential of single grain feldspar luminescence dating applied to late Holocene cyclone and tsunami deposits, for which complete signal resetting can a priori not be guaranteed. To address potential problems of feldspar dating of such deposits associated with heterogeneous bleaching, remnant doses and anomalous fading, we use a low-temperature post infrared infrared stimulated luminescence protocol (pIRIR
150) on single grains. For most samples, good agreement between fading corrected IR
50 and non-fading corrected pIRIR
150 ages is observed. Both feldspar ages generally also show good agreement with age control provided by historical data and quartz luminescence ages. pIRIR
150 remnant ages in modern analogue samples are shown to be < 50 years, indicating that dating accuracy might be negatively affected by insufficient signal zeroing only for sediments younger than ∼500 years. As these minor remnant ages are interpreted as being caused by unbleachable luminescence residuals, slight age overestimation for young samples can be overcome by subtracting the remnant ages. The good agreement between pIRIR
150, IR
50 and quartz ages, indicates that a significant number of grains must have experienced relatively complete signal resetting during or immediately prior to transport, as the three signals are known to bleach at different rates. Since light exposure during the event is expected to be limited, we deduce that a significant portion of the grains in the cyclone and tsunami deposits was already bleached prior to the event of interest. These well-bleached grains were likely eroded at the beach, while other grains with larger remnant ages probably originate from the shallow subtidal, coastal barriers or even further inland sources. Additional signal resetting during storm and tsunami transport is indicated by slightly younger quartz than feldspar ages for grains with incomplete pre-transport resetting that were eroded at the Holocene coastal barrier.
AB - Quartz is the preferred dosimeter for luminescence dating of Holocene sediments as optically stimulated luminescence (OSL) signals reset rapidly upon light exposure, and are stable over time. However, feldspar is required where quartz luminescence properties are inappropriate for dating, as is often the case in geologically young mountain ranges and areas with young volcanism. Here we aim to evaluate the potential of single grain feldspar luminescence dating applied to late Holocene cyclone and tsunami deposits, for which complete signal resetting can a priori not be guaranteed. To address potential problems of feldspar dating of such deposits associated with heterogeneous bleaching, remnant doses and anomalous fading, we use a low-temperature post infrared infrared stimulated luminescence protocol (pIRIR
150) on single grains. For most samples, good agreement between fading corrected IR
50 and non-fading corrected pIRIR
150 ages is observed. Both feldspar ages generally also show good agreement with age control provided by historical data and quartz luminescence ages. pIRIR
150 remnant ages in modern analogue samples are shown to be < 50 years, indicating that dating accuracy might be negatively affected by insufficient signal zeroing only for sediments younger than ∼500 years. As these minor remnant ages are interpreted as being caused by unbleachable luminescence residuals, slight age overestimation for young samples can be overcome by subtracting the remnant ages. The good agreement between pIRIR
150, IR
50 and quartz ages, indicates that a significant number of grains must have experienced relatively complete signal resetting during or immediately prior to transport, as the three signals are known to bleach at different rates. Since light exposure during the event is expected to be limited, we deduce that a significant portion of the grains in the cyclone and tsunami deposits was already bleached prior to the event of interest. These well-bleached grains were likely eroded at the beach, while other grains with larger remnant ages probably originate from the shallow subtidal, coastal barriers or even further inland sources. Additional signal resetting during storm and tsunami transport is indicated by slightly younger quartz than feldspar ages for grains with incomplete pre-transport resetting that were eroded at the Holocene coastal barrier.
KW - single grain dating
KW - feldspar dating
KW - post infrared infrared stimulated luminescence
KW - Tsunami deposit
KW - cyclone deposit
KW - transport processes
KW - Feldspar dating
KW - Cyclone deposit
KW - Transport processes
KW - Single grain dating
KW - Post infrared infrared stimulated luminescence
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85053397027&partnerID=8YFLogxK
U2 - 10.1016/j.quageo.2018.09.001
DO - 10.1016/j.quageo.2018.09.001
M3 - Article
SN - 1871-1014
VL - 48
SP - 91
EP - 103
JO - Quaternary Geochronology
JF - Quaternary Geochronology
ER -